Task A
1.
Sum up Keri Leigh Merritt’s account of the situation in the state of Mississippi in the past and present.
(Comprehension) (12 Punkte)
2.
Analyse the way Merritt makes her point. Focus on communicative strategies and use of language.
(Analysis) (16 Punkte)
3.
Choose one of the following tasks:
3.1
Assess Merritt’s claim that “Jackson’s problems, like those of so many other US towns and cities, are a blight on the political ideals White Americans traditionally claim” (ll. 23 – 24). Refer to the text as well as work done in class on American myths and realities.
(Evaluation: comment) (14 Punkte)
3.2
You have been asked to give the opening speech at the international youth conference Towards a More Inclusive and Sustainable Planet. In your research, you have come across UNESCO’s director general Audrey Azoulay’s claim that water is “a ‘blue gold’ to which more than 2 billion people do not have direct access”1 and decided to use it as a starting point. Write the speech script, referring to work done in class on ecological, political and economic issues of globalisation.
[1] Audrey Azoulay, in: Unesco, “UN World Water Development 2021” http://www.unesco.org/reports/wwdr/2021/en (Zugriff: 30.06.2021)
(Evaluation: re-creation of text) (14 Punkte)
Keri Leigh Merritt Jackson water crisis shows Nina Simone is still right about Mississippi
1
Summoned to the South by Marian Wright of the NAACP, Senators Robert F. Kennedy and
2
Joseph Clark traveled to the Mississippi Delta in the Spring of 1967 to assess the effectiveness
3
of the federal War on Poverty programs. Wright had testified before Congress that the people
4
of her state were starving and in agony. Although forewarned, the White senators were stunned
5
to witness the extremities of Mississippi’s soul-crushing poverty, right in the middle of one
6
of the wealthiest nations on earth.
7
After repeated attempts to engage one young, seemingly non-verbal African American boy
8
– his stomach swollen from malnourishment – picking through dried rice and beans on the
9
dirt floor of a shack, Bobby Kennedy, the father of 11 children, quickly turned and walked
10
outside. He did not want the photographers who accompanied him to catch the tears welling
11
up in his eyes.
12
The depth of Mississippi’s poverty was almost too much for Kennedy to bear. Speaking
13
mournfully about “children with distended stomachs,” Kennedy urged the federal government
14
to do something to alleviate the state’s widespread “suffering”. Deeming “housing inadequate”
15
and commenting on the “insufficient clothing” of the state’s impoverished children, he
16
rightfully concluded that Mississippi was a “terrible reflection on our society”.
17
Now, 54 years later, it is necessary to ask the federal government to intervene in the state
18
again. Many of the primarily Black residents of Mississippi’s capital, Jackson, spent weeks
19
without running water after a cold spell burst a huge number of the city’s pipes. According
20
to Mississippi Today, over 40,000 people, the equivalent of a sold-out game at Wrigley Field,
21
were not able to drink, bathe or wash clothes, dishes, hands or even flush toilets – all during
22
a pandemic. […]
23
Jackson’s problems, like those of so many other US towns and cities, are a blight on the
24
political ideals White Americans traditionally claim.
25
Jackson, Mississippi, is a microcosm of our nation’s massive failures to make amends for
26
centuries of colonialism, slavery and racism. […]
27
Our problem, our shame, is that American poverty springs not from lack of funds, but instead
28
from White supremacy. Due to the ravages of history – from slavery and the failures of
29
Reconstruction to more modern tactics of redlining, White flight and the crisis of mass incarceration –
30
poverty in America is almost always dependent on racism, even when the
31
impoverished are White. From pitting laborers of different races against each other to stoking
32
racist and xenophobic fears through a sensationalistic and profit-driven media, America’s
33
White elite have always used the specter of racism to prevent the formation of a broad coalition
34
of people with similar class interests, regardless of race.
35
And poor and working-class Whites historically have been all-too-willing to join in this
36
Faustian bargain.
37
We are one of the richest nations in the world, but among those nations, we are one of the
38
most unequal. Nearly all other developed nations offer a better standard of living to their
39
citizens, regardless of income or wealth.
40
Currently, White Republicans control Mississippi’s state legislature. As Mississippi Free Press
41
reported, Governor Tate Reeves and other White lawmakers are essentially holding the
42
Black-led, Black-populated city hostage, refusing to fund repairs. While the citizens of his
43
state are literally going on a month without the very basics of survival, Reeves instead focused
44
his attention to passing the nation’s first anti-transgender law of 2021.
45
The few repairs that have been made have mostly been in affluent, largely White north
46
Jackson, clearly delineating not just the privileges, but the power of Whiteness. […]
47
Although reparate is no longer a common word, it is the key to successfully addressing
48
reparations. To reparate means to restore something to a state of good repair; it means
49
returning something to working order. Reparative justice means to right the wrongs of the
50
past – not only by acknowledging the harms of certain groups of people both in the past and
51
the present, but also addressing those harms and working to ameliorate them.
52
As Nina Simone so brilliantly wrote about reparative justice in her iconic song “Mississippi
53
Goddam”, time is always of the essence:
54
But that’s just the trouble
55
“do it slow“
56
Desegregation
57
“do it slow“
58
Mass participation
59
“do it slow“
60
Reunification
61
“do it slow“
62
Do things gradually
63
“do it slow“
64
But bring more tragedy.
65
While many White Mississippians in power like Tate Reeves and other GOP leaders – wittingly
66
or not – extend the legacies of racism and the slaveholders’ Confederacy and fail to act as
67
White supremacy keeps state’s people ensnared in extreme poverty, the time for federal
68
intervention is now. If the leaders of the state will not repair and restore Jackson’s water
69
system, then the leaders of the country must step in to help right the wrongs of the past.
70
From immediately sending FEMA in to deal with Jackson’s short-term problems to passing
71
a Federal Jobs Guarantee that focuses, first and foremost, on reparative justice, the Biden
72
administration and the Democratic Congress – if they truly espouse the values they
73
campaigned upon – should act swiftly and thoroughly.
74
In 1968, less than a year after Senator Kennedy’s Mississippi trip, Martin Luther King, Jr.
75
wrote that “There is nothing new about poverty. What is new is that we now have the techniques
76
and the resources to get rid of poverty. The real question is whether we have the will.”
77
It is nothing short of a moral and ethical tragedy – an indictment of the entire country – that
78
our citizens are being deprived of clean running water in one of the richest nations on earth.
79
It is well past time for immediate federal action. We must have the will.
80
Mississippi Goddam.
Aus: Keri Leigh Merritt, “Jackson water crisis shows Nina Simone is still right about Mississippi”, in: CNN, 14 March 2021 https://edition.cnn.com/2021/03/14/opinions/jackson-mississippi-water-crisis-racism-and-poverty-merritt/index.html (Zugriff: 17.06.2021)
Weiter lernen mit SchulLV-PLUS!
monatlich kündbarSchulLV-PLUS-Vorteile im ÜberblickDu hast bereits einen Account?
Note:
Our solutions are listed in bullet points. In the examination, full marks can only be achieved by writing a continuous text.
Our solutions are listed in bullet points. In the examination, full marks can only be achieved by writing a continuous text.
1.
The article from Keri Leigh Merritt "Jackson water crisis shows Nina Simone is still right about Mississippi" published in CNN 2021 is about the past and present situation in the state of Mississippi.
Introduction
- situation was characterized by poverty, hunger and sorrow
- it was described as "soul-crushing poverty in one of the wealthiest nations on earth" (l. 5/6)
- there was only inadequate housing, insufficient clothing, and widespread suffering (l. 14/15)
Main Body
Situation from the past
Situation from the past
- the situation in Mississippi has not changed fundamentally, as evidenced by the fact that the capital city of Jackson, for example, was without running water for some time due to the burst of city pipes
- until today, the state is characterized by poverty, despite the fact that there are certainly the means to fight it
Present situation
2.
- Merritt illustrates the poor living conditions in which Mississippi's inhabitants live by contrasting the situation of the past with that of the present
- used linguistic devices, as well as communicative strategies, have an impact on how the reader perceives Mississippi's situation
Introduction
Reference to task and thesis
Reference to task and thesis
- the author refers to important people like senators etc. and thus creates authenticity
- by using quotes from the senator,"children with distended" (l. 13), "suffering" (l. 14), "housing inadequate" (l. 14), and "insufficient clothing" (l. 15), the author emphasizes his reliability and highlights therefore his statements
- the use of colloquial language "Mississippi Goddam" (l. 80) provides authenticity, creates closeness to the reader and again clarifies the author's attitude towards the subject matter
- the author uses the comparison of past and present to show that nothing has changed in the living situation
Main Body
Communicative strategies
Communicative strategies
- comparison "... the equivalent of a sold-out game at Wrigley-Field ..." (l. 20) used to illustrate how great the size of people is suffering from poverty and poor living standards
- enumeration and arranged in an anticlimax "... not able to drink, bathe or wash clothes, dishes, hands or even flush toilets - all during a pandemic." (l. 21/33) used to highlight how much these people suffered from the circumstances
- the excerpt of a song by Nina Simone l. 54 - 64 in form of a anaphora and parallelism
- there is continuous reference to mississippi's brutal racist past, and emotive language with negative connotations such as "racism," "slaveholders," "poverty," which indisputably contributed to the state's poverty and thus to the poor living conditions of its society
- repeated use of superlatives and hyperoles "richest nations in the world ... most unequal" (l. 37/38) or "extreme poverty" to show the great depth of contrast in which the state is divided in
- appeal and inclusive language is used "...the time for federal intervention is now..." (l. 68) or "We must have the will." (l. 79) to call society to action to change something
Linguistic devices
- all in all, it can be said that Merritt makes the point with her comparison that not very much has changed about Mississippi's situation since 1967
- by using a variety of linguistic devices she emphazises the extremly poor living conditions, thus clarifies its point and calling to action
Conclusion
3.1
“Jackson’s problems, like those of so many other US towns and cities, are a blight on the political ideals White Americans traditionally claim”
- Merritt's claim refers to the poor living situation for many Americans even though the country is usually represented as the without limits where everything is possible
- whether Merritt's assertion can be proven true or falsified is evaluated in the following statement
Introduction
- the political ideals White Americans represent are, at their core, those America presents to the outside world:
- the US as one of the richest nations of the world in which all is possible
- where a better, happier, and freer life full of social equality for all citizens of all ranks is possible
- where the beliefs and values are: pursuit of happiness, liberty, equality
- the declaration of independence that includes at its core these hopes and beliefs for the American dream
Main Body
Political ideals of Whites
Political ideals of Whites
- Jackson is only one of the example of America's failed policy
- it's a city plagued by racism, poverty, and slavery
- the main problem is that change is not possible due to "white supremacy" and, the ravages of history, failures of reconstruction, and persistent racism (cf. l. 28-30)
- Merritt's claims that poverty in America is almost always linked to racism, even when the impoverished are white (cf. l. 30/31)
- if you look at the history as well as the current events, it is clear that racism has been a very big problem in the states to date
- Movements like the Black Lives Matter movement have proven that minorities are still oppressed and suffer from violence and disadvantage
- during the presidencies of republicans like Trump, for instance, the country's social situation has also worsened, causing many people to suffer, especially those from low-income families
- politicians agree, however, that something must be done about poverty, but draw too little of a connection to combating racism
Problems of US town's and cities
- Merritt's statement may well be considered accurate, even though politicians agree that something needs to be done, but cities like Jackson represent the failure of government
Conclusion
3.2
Welcome dear fellows,
- thank you very much for everyone being here today, to participate in changing our world into a more sustainable one
- I will start talking about the blue gold, the source of life, H2O or you can simply call it water - one of the most valuable resources on our planet and a vital good for all its inhabitants
- although the surface of our earth is covered with 70% water, the drinkable water supply is actually only 1%. UNESCO's director Audrey Azonlay claims that water is "a ‘blue gold’ to which more than 2 billion people do not have direct access"
- this statement should be a call to action for everyone. Each one of us has to to change and overthink our behavior, because all of us are responsible for the decreasing water availability
- rising consumption, expanding globalization, and the increasing interconnection of the world is one of the reason for water scarcity.
- and this dear is my motife of speaking to you today
- it's a shocking fact of which we and everyone else ought to be aware of and to rethink their behavior
Greeting and introduction
- undoubtedly does have the globalization its good sides, however, do we have to be aware of it exacerbating environmental pressures, inequalities, and poverty
- insufficient access to water sources for people from, for instance, Africa, Latin America and Asia, but also the lack of water resources
- every person in the consumer society contributes fundamentally to the aggravation of inequalities with his or her consumption behavior
- due to globalization the fast pace of our world has accelerated, capitalism has increased and we have become a throwaway society
- productions have increased and with it the worlds water consumption
- thus the scarce drinking water resources are very unevenly distributed
- groundwater is used up faster than it is replenished by precipitation
Main Body
Globalization as cause for water scarcity
Globalization as cause for water scarcity
- our and society's consumption behavior must definitely change, with more sustainable purchases and less waste being thrown away
- introduce more sustainability into production processes and implement it along the value chain
- we need to raise awareness among the people around us and show them how great their impact is on others and especially on less advantaged people's lives
- a change in behavior is necessary away from buying imported goods back to regional goods
Recommendations for action and precautions
- Water scarcity is a very serious issue and more and more people are suffering from it every year
- all in all, it is important that we change our entire behavior to a more sustainable one and realize what the consequences will be if we do not change it
Conclusion