Aufgabe I
Aufgabenstellung
1.
Describe the situation in the shop.
(30%)
2.
Examine Merle's character.
(30%)
3.
You want to take part in an online seminar at the University of Houston on the migrant experience titled "The Quest for True Belonging and the Courage to Stand Alone," which is offered by social scientist Brené Brown. As a prerequisite for attendance, you have to hand in an essay commenting on her statement "Fitting in is not belonging."
Write the essay, also referring to the text at hand and materials studied in class, such as the short stories by Lahiri, Levy, Pandit, and Shahraz.
(40%)
Text: Excerpt from Yvvette Edwards, “Security” (2019)
1
Merle noticed the security guard the moment she stepped through the entrance of
2
Penny World: a tall, heavy-set white man, mid-forties, who had positioned himself on
3
top of a barstool at the front of the store to have an unobstructed view of customers
4
entering; and she knew he’d clocked her, because he stood up straightaway, trying
5
to make the action seem natural by generally surveying the store, as if that had been
6
his intention all along, and it surprised her, the anger she felt – hot and rapid, erupting
7
inside her chest like a volcano come to life – surprised her at a time when she was
8
upset with so many other things, proper problems with longevity attached, that this
9
incident, when she’d just popped out to pick up some Sure deodorant and a roll of
10
clingfilm, was the blow that finally swept her over the edge.
11
Her flight was tomorrow morning at 11 and arrangements had been made to pick her
12
up at 5 a.m. so she didn’t miss it. She’d bought the suitcase last week, had to, because
13
the only one she’d ever owned was the one she’d brought with her when she made
14
the six-week boat journey from Jamaica to England in June 1964, which had for years
15
been reclining on top of her wardrobe, the metal handle broken, clasps defunct,
16
reduced in status to a storage container, nothing more. She’d not been back to
17
Jamaica since arriving here, had never gone on holiday abroad, never had need of a
18
passport, and here she was, at the age of seventy-eight, making the journey back [...].
19
Seventy-eight years of age, and with the neat and tidy way she always dressed and
20
carried herself, were she a stranger trying to work out what kind of person she might
21
be, the word that would have come to mind is church. Despite this, in the fifty-four
22
years she’d been living in England and spending her money in shops with security
23
guards, she’d regularly been followed around like a thief.
24
Forty-one of those fifty-four years she’d worked as a care assistant in homes for the
25
elderly, spoon-feeding geriatrics, dressing and undressing them, giving herself back
26
problems that plagued her to this day, from lifting them in and out of bed and bath,
27
on and off seats, toilets, floors; cleaning their dirty behinds and infronts, their soiled
28
bedding, while acting like it was just sticks and stones to have them tell herthey didn’t
29
want her black hands touching them, their food, their cutlery and medicine cups.
30
She’d been watched with suspicion by those same people she’d looked after,
31
watched as she mopped up all manner of nastiness, as if the only reason she dressed
32
in the uniform her employers issued, wearing gloves and carrying a mop and bucket,
33
was to rob them of the little shekels in purses and wallets they hid under mattresses
34
and at the back of their drawers. And had she harboured any grudges against them?
35
Nope. She had not. [...]
36
Merle dawdled as she approached the end of the aisle, handling products she had no
37
intention of buying, touching everything she felt like, without a backward glance.
38
Then, as she rounded the corner, out of the security guard’s sight, she began
39
marching briskly, nearly but not quite running, careful not to slip or trip and mash up
40
her seventy-eight-year-old body, hurrying only as fast as she could manage safely,
41
because if she injured herself, they’d probably say she’d done it on purpose to avoid
42
the flight, and God alone knew whether after all the years of paying National
43
Insurance contributions from her wages, she’d be entitled to treatment from the
44
National Health Service. She scurried determinedly down Aisle 2 and around the
45
corner so she was back in Aisle 1, continued swiftly along it, then for the second time
46
rounded the top, slowing only when she spotted the security guard a few feet ahead,
47
facing away from her, body alert, his head pinging back and forth like a meerkat, no
48
doubt wondering where the old lady had vanished. She stopped immediately behind
49
him, and as he turned around in confusion, Merle picked up a column of fifty
50
disposable cups and stared at it, trying to calm her breathing, while joyfully basking
51
in the vibe of his astonishment at discovering the woman he’d been following was
52
now behind him. [...]
53
She said, “It doesn’t feel very nice, does it?”
54
The security guard’s voice was deep, bassy, tinged with a strong accent that Merle
55
couldn’t narrow down further than Eastern European. He said, “My job, stop steal.”
56
The fact of his accent broke her; she didn’t know why. It made no difference to what
57
had happened, to this latest affront. Was it because despite being new to the country,
58
he’d been endowed with the authority to treat her like a criminal? Did she feel
59
because he wasn’t British, he didn’t have the right? Or because until he opened his
60
mouth he’d been able to pass, to silently position himself within the system like a
61
native, whereas fifty-four years on, she was still being made to feel like a foreigner?
62
Now a foreigner officially.
63
She said, “Well you won’t have to worry about this woman stealing ever again. You’ll
64
be happy to know, I’m being deported.” [...]
65
At the till, after she had paid for her items and packed them in the carrier bag she’d
66
brought along, she noticed the security guard was sitting on his barstool again, and
67
realised she’d have to pass him on her way to the exit. She’d decided to just ignore
68
him, but as she approached his perch, he gave her a smile and she was unable to
69
interpret what it was meant to convey. Solidarity? Pity? Glee?
70
Her pace slowed, but she did not stop. Reflected in his glasses she saw a proud old
71
lady, head held high. Her voice was steady as she spoke: “It’s me today, but
72
tomorrow, they’ll be back for you.”
(994 words)
Yvvette Edwards. “Security.” New Daughters of Africa. Ed. Margaret Busby. Oxford: Myriad, 2019. 336-340.
Weiter lernen mit SchulLV-PLUS!
monatlich kündbarSchulLV-PLUS-Vorteile im ÜberblickDu hast bereits einen Account?
Note:
Our solutions are listed in bullet points. In the examination, full marks can only be achieved by writing a continuous text.
Our solutions are listed in bullet points. In the examination, full marks can only be achieved by writing a continuous text.
1.
- Merle, a seventy-eight-year-old Jamaican migrant, entered the store named Penny World
- she is looking for some goods in the shop
- noticed immediately a security guard following her
- Merle felt a surge of anger given that she was already upset due to other personal problems
- despite her age and neat appearance, she had often been wrongly suspected of theft in stores with security guards
- decided to reverse the roles and follow the guard in order to approach him and confront him with the experience of having been wrongly followed
- is told by the guard that he is in charge of preventing shoplifting
- the security guard, with an accent probably also being a migrant, explained that his job was to prevent theft
- Merle informed him of her impending deportation, signaling she wouldn't steal
- reminds him of the possibility of facing deportation one day himself
- Merle left the store with her head held high, pondering her uncertain future
Describing the situation
2.
- background
Merle is a seventy-eight-year-old migrant from Jamaica, who's facing deportation (l.14-18, l. 64)
"she made the six-week boat journey from Jamaica to England in June 1964 " (l. 13f.)
- observant
noticed the security guard right at the beginning (l.1)
- blending in to avoid attention
"the neat and tidy way she always dressed and carried herself […], the word that would have come to mind is church" l. 19-21)
- dedicated and hard-working
"spoon-feeding geriatrics, dressing and undressing them, giving herself back problems that plagued her to this day, from lifting them in and out of bed and bath," (l. 25f.)
- "She’d been watched with suspicion by those same people she’d looked after..." (l. 30)
hardworking even when facing discrimination as a Care Assistant
- resilient and forgiving despite having faced discrimination
"And had she harboured any grudges against them? Nope. She had not. [...]" (l. 41f.)
- self-conciously trying to avoid making mistakes
"careful not to slip or trip [...] because if she injured herself, they’d probably" (l. 39-43)
- purposeful and courageous
Merle doesn't back down when confronting the security guard
"marching briskly" (l. 39) "scurried determinedly" (l.44) "while joyfully basking in the vibe of his astonishment" (l. 50f.)
- frustrated by the system
that considers other migrants superior while excluding her
"despite being new to the country, he’d been endowed with the authority to treat her like a criminal " (l. 57f.)
"she was still being made to feel like a foreigner" l. 61)
"It’s me today, but tomorrow, they’ll be back for you." (l. 71f.)
Character
3.
In the passage from Yvvette Edwards' "Security," we are introduced to Merle, a character who embodies the complexities of the migrant experience, as well as the theme that "fitting in is not belonging." This theme resonates deeply with the stories we have explored in class, particularly those of Lahiri, Levy, Pandit, and Shahraz.
Introduction
- Merle has made significant efforts to conform and fit into her new surroundings
- the narrators in "Loose Change" and "She Shall Not Be Moved" go to great lengths to behave in ways that align with typical British customs
- narrator in "The Third and Final Continent" demonstrates a remarkable ability to effortlessly adapt to different customs, balancing his Indian roots and American life
- Samir in "The Escape" fully considers Britain as his homeland and even moves into an old people's home, illustrating a deep degree of willingness to modify his behavior to integrate into British society
Main Body
Assimilation and Adaptation
Assimilation and Adaptation
- Merle, despite her efforts to integrate, is still often treated as an outsider, threatened with deportation, indicating a lack of acceptance by the community
- in contrast, the narrator and his wife Mala, in "The Third and Final Continent", are warmly accepted by their American landlady and her daughter, reflecting the positive aspect of integrating into a new community
- the two white women in "She Shall Not Be Moved" refuse to stand up for the Somali woman, highlighting instances of exclusion and a lack of acceptance by the community
Acceptance by the Community
- Merle, in her pursuit of fitting in, has relinquished much of her connection to her West Indian heritage, sacrificing her identity in the process
- Samir in "The Escape" is depicted as someone who maintains his Muslim rituals in his private life, indicating his commitment to preserving his cultural and religious identity
- in "The Third and Final Continent" the narrator and his wife, Mala, manage to strike a balance between both of their cultures, illustrating the importance of maintaining one's identity while adapting to a new environment
Preserving identity
- in "Loose Change," Laylor is left by the narrator, emphasizing the significance of friendship in the migrant experience and the impact of abandonment
- Samir in "The Escape" receives substantial support from family members in both Britain and Pakistan, highlighting the role of familial relationships in helping migrants navigate their new lives
- Mala, after her arrival in the U.S.A., relies on guidance from her husband, reinforcing the importance of spousal support when adapting to a foreign culture
- Somali woman in "She Shall Not Be Moved" exemplifies the vulnerability and isolation experienced by migrants when they lack a support network in their adopted homeland
Importance of friendship
- in conclusion, Brené Brown's statement, "Fitting in is not belonging," holds a profound significance in the context of the migrant experience and the pursuit of true belonging
- the characters in these stories by Lahiri, Levy, Pandit, and Shahraz illustrate this profound quest for true belonging
- true belonging comes from embracing one's uniqueness while being accepted for who they are, not conforming to fit in.
- all in all, a journey that requires individuals to stand firmly in their authenticity, rejecting conformity and celebrating diversity
Conclusion